FDD Item 19 Financial Performance Representation: How to Read It and Use It

Candidate comparing Item 19 financial figures with a spreadsheet

An FDD Item 19 financial performance representation is the one place a franchisor is allowed to tell you, in writing, how its existing locations have performed. It's optional, it's easy to misread, and it's the closest thing the document gives you to a financial answer. It still isn't one.

I covered the whole document in how to read a Franchise Disclosure Document. This post stays on one topic. Here's how I read Item 19, what I look for before I trust a number, and what to do when it isn't there.

What an FDD Item 19 financial performance representation actually is

Under the Federal Trade Commission's Franchise Rule, a financial performance representation is any statement, written, oral, or visual, that states or implies a specific level or range of actual or potential sales, income, gross profits, or net profits. The FTC's Consumer's Guide to Buying a Franchise explains the rule in plain English.

The rule is simple on one point. If a franchisor wants to talk about what its locations earn, that information belongs in Item 19, and the franchisor needs a reasonable basis and written backup for it that it will show you on request.

Here's what Item 19 isn't. It isn't a forecast, and it isn't a promise. It describes what some other people did, over some period, under their own circumstances. Your job is to figure out how much of that carries over to you.

You have at least 14 calendar days between receiving the FDD and signing anything or paying any money. This is the section of the document where I'd spend a good share of them.

Gross versus net: which number are you looking at?

Item 19s don't all report the same thing. Some show gross sales or revenue. Some show average unit volume. Some show gross profit, some show a profit measure like EBITDA, and a few show something closer to owner earnings. The rule doesn't hand every franchisor the same yardstick, so the first question is always: what's this number, exactly?

Gross sales tell you how much money moved through the business. They don't tell you what was left. Royalties and other fees from Item 6, product costs shaped by Item 8, rent, payroll, insurance, and loan payments all come out before anyone takes a paycheck.

Even a profit figure needs a closer look. Ask what was counted as an expense and what wasn't.

  • Did the figure include a salary for the owner, or did the owner work for free?
  • Were royalties and marketing fund contributions already subtracted?
  • Were interest and loan payments left out? If you finance the business, those are real to you. Item 10 covers any financing the franchisor offers.
  • Was the owner's family working in the business without pay?

Then put the answer next to Item 7. A strong gross number sitting on top of a heavy investment range tells a different story than the same number on a lean one. If you want the investment side in detail, I walk through it in what it costs to become a franchisee.

Averages, medians, and why the middle matters

An average is easy to like. It's one number, and franchisors tend to show it. The trouble is that a few big locations can pull an average well above what most owners actually see.

Picture five owners. Four of them land close together, and one does far more than the rest. That one pulls the average up, so four of the five sit below it. The median is the owner in the middle.

That doesn't mean the franchisor is hiding anything. It means the average alone can't tell you what a typical owner experiences.

What I like to see is the median next to the average, plus the range. The best Item 19s break results into tiers, like the top group, the middle, and the bottom, so you can see what the spread really looks like. If all you're given is one average, ask if there's a median and a range behind it.

Also check the time frame. Is it one year or several? Does it say which years? A strong year for the whole industry can make anyone look good.

Subsets and sample size: who is actually in the numbers?

Read the footnotes first. In Item 19, the footnotes are the content.

Who got left out

A franchisor is allowed to report on a subset of its locations, for example only those open a certain length of time, only one region, or only the top group. That's legal. If the figures come from one region, ask how it compares with the territory you'd actually be getting. When it happens, the rule expects the franchisor to tell you how many locations, and what percentage of the system, actually reached those results, and what the basis is.

So do the arithmetic yourself. Take the number of outlets in the Item 19 figures and compare it to the outlet counts in Item 20. If the numbers cover a small slice of the system, you're looking at that slice, not the system.

Survivors and closed locations

Item 19 usually describes the locations that are still operating. Item 20 shows you the ones that closed, transferred, or were taken back. Read them together. A great set of survivor numbers means something different when a lot of owners left.

Company-owned versus franchised

Some Item 19s include locations the franchisor owns itself. Those can run differently than yours will: different staffing, different costs, and sometimes better sites. Ask whether the figures separate company-owned from franchised.

Sample size

If the figures come from a handful of locations, treat them as a few data points and not a pattern. Small samples swing a lot. That's one more reason the owner calls matter.

What it means when Item 19 is absent

Item 19 is the one optional item in the FDD. Plenty of franchisors leave it out. That's legal, and in a newer or smaller system it isn't automatically a warning sign.

It does change your workload. With no Item 19, the document won't give you a financial picture, so you build it from conversations with owners. That's slower, and it's doable.

The one thing I won't let slide is a number that shows up out loud and nowhere in writing. The rule exists so that earnings claims are in Item 19, with backup behind them. If someone is quoting you what “a typical owner makes” and it isn't in the document, ask where it comes from, and put it on my list of franchise red flags to watch.

How to turn Item 19 and owner calls into your own pro forma

A pro forma is just your own projected profit and loss. It's built from evidence, not from the brochure. If Item 19 is the franchisor's view, the pro forma is yours.

Start with revenue you can defend

Use the median if there is one, not the best-case average. Then adjust for the fact that a new location doesn't open at the volume of a mature one. Ask the owners how many months it took them to get there. Item 11 will tell you how long the franchisor says it takes to open, and that's a different clock from the one that starts after you open.

Load every cost from the FDD

Pull royalties and fees from Item 6, build-out and opening costs from Item 7, and required suppliers from Item 8. Add rent, payroll, insurance, and the fees that quietly keep going, like technology and local marketing.

Pay yourself, and decide who runs it

Put a real salary in the model, either for you or for a manager. Item 15 tells you whether the franchisor expects you on site. If you plan to step back, the manager's pay comes out of the profit.

Add the debt

If you're borrowing, put the loan payment in the model. Cash flow after debt is the number that matters, and it's why I want you to look at financing options and liquid capital requirements before you fall in love with a revenue line.

Test it on the owners

This is the step that turns a spreadsheet into something real. Call owners from the Item 20 list and put your assumptions in front of them. Is my labor line realistic? What did your first twelve months look like? What costs surprised you? Anything that doesn't line up is worth raising with the franchisor at discovery day.

Get three owners on the phone before you drop a brand, and five before you pick one. My post on how to validate a franchise covers how to run those calls. Be nosy when you do.

Build three versions: conservative, expected, and strong. If the conservative one still works, you may have something. If it only works when everything goes right, that tells you something too.

Then add the cost of growing past opening day: the marketing push, the extra vehicle, the first employee. None of that shows up in a revenue line.

Where the gap comes from

When the top of the range is far above the middle, it's tempting to credit the brand. Usually it isn't the brand. It's behavior. The owners at the top are doing something the owners in the middle aren't.

So the question that matters most isn't what the top number is. It's what those owners do every week, and whether you're ready, willing, and able to do the same, yourself or through someone you hire.

Item 19 can show you what other owners did. It can't tell you why you'd do this. For anyone to make a change, you have to have what I call a compelling emotional reason. Know yours before you dig into anyone's numbers, and you'll read them for fit instead of hope.

Where I fit

My part is walking with you from that first conversation about what you want, through the FDD and the owner calls, all the way to a decision. Walking away counts as one. I do this as an independent franchise consultant; how I'm paid is in my royalty fees guide.

Where to start

If you're holding an FDD and the numbers in Item 19 aren't adding up, or you haven't gotten that far and want to know if franchising fits you, start with the quiz. A few minutes of answers lets our first conversation start where you actually are.

Take the quiz

Rather have a conversation first? The contact form gets you a free 15-minute consultation with me, no matter where you live. You can also start from the home page to see how I work.

Frequently Asked Questions About FDD Item 19

A financial performance representation, or FPR, is any statement that gives a specific level or range of actual or potential sales, income, gross profits, or net profits. Under the FTC Franchise Rule, a franchisor that makes one has to put it in Item 19 of the FDD and have a reasonable basis and written backup for it. It describes what other locations did, not what you'll do.

No. Item 19 is the only optional item in the Franchise Disclosure Document. A franchisor can leave it out, and many do, especially newer or smaller systems. Leaving it out is legal and isn't automatically a warning sign, but it means the financial picture comes from what current owners tell you.

There are a few reasons, and most of them are ordinary. A newer system may not have enough open locations to report anything meaningful, and some franchisors feel results vary too much from one owner to the next for a single set of figures to be fair. Others would rather not put numbers in writing, since the franchisor has to back up whatever it says. I treat a missing Item 19 as a question to ask, not a verdict, and then I build the picture through owner calls from Item 20.

Matt Stevens, independent franchise consultant with nearly 40 years of experience

Matt Stevens Independent Franchise Consultant, The Franchise Guy

Nearly 40 Years in Franchising  |  4 Businesses Owned  |  Nearly 1,000 Franchisees Placed  |  heisthefranchiseguy.com

Matt Stevens has spent nearly 40 years in franchising. He’s helped more than 3,000 people explore franchise ownership and placed nearly 1,000 of them as franchisees across more than 40 states. He has owned four businesses and served as Vice President and Partner in a $2 billion international franchise holding company. He works as an independent franchise consultant based in Dublin, Ohio, and his consulting is free to the candidate. Learn more about Matt

Published:  |  Last Updated:  |  LinkedIn

Ready to Find the Right Franchise for You?

Matt Stevens  |  The Franchise Guy  |  Dublin, OH 43016

Call: (614) 595-3726

Book My Free Consultation

Related Posts

Franchise Territory: How to Read Item 12 of the FDD

Franchise Territory: How to Read Item 12 of the FDD

A franchise territory is only as strong as the wording in Item 12. Here's how I read protected, exclusive, and…
Franchise Royalty Fees: What You Pay After You Open

Franchise Royalty Fees: What You Pay After You Open

What you pay the franchisor after you open: royalties (percent of gross or flat), brand fund, technology, renewal and transfer…
FDD Item 19 Financial Performance Representation: How to Read It and Use It

FDD Item 19 Financial Performance Representation: How to Read It and Use It

Item 19 is the one place a franchisor can tell you, in writing, how its existing locations have performed. I…