How to Evaluate a Franchise Opportunity: Matt Stevens on The CEO Project Podcast with Jim Schleckser

Podcast cover image for The Franchise Guy featuring Jim Schleckser and Matt Stevens.

Most people spend more time researching a used car than they do a franchise investment. On The CEO Project Podcast with host Jim Schleckser, Matt Stevens breaks down what experienced candidates actually do differently: how they read an FDD, which questions unlock the truth, and why the right franchise fits your life before it fits your spreadsheet.

Key Takeaways from This Episode

  • Franchising spans 80-plus industries and over 4,000 brands, a breadth most candidates never discover on their own.
  • Great franchisors earn on royalties, not fees. A system profiting on the franchise fee is a warning sign.
  • The Franchise Disclosure Document is your single most important research tool. Know what to look for in the turnover data.
  • B2B franchises are a natural fit for corporate professionals: recurring revenue, relationship sales, and no storefront overhead.
  • Schedule flexibility varies enormously by category. Home services and painting businesses let owners control their calendars in ways retail almost never does.
  • Senior care is a standout: 40 to 70 franchise systems nationwide, a growing market, and high personal satisfaction for owners who connect with the mission.
  • Every candidate needs a compelling emotional reason. Without one, the learning curve, the financial commitment, and the vulnerability of starting over become too much.
Matt Stevens on The CEO Project Podcast with Jim Schleckser discussing how to evaluate a franchise opportunity

Why Business Owners Choose Franchising as a Growth Path

Franchising is one of several ways to scale a business, but it is the one that lets owners grow nationally without diluting equity. Instead of raising outside capital the way a startup might, a franchisor uses the money and entrepreneurial drive of individual franchisees who build their own locations under a shared brand. The franchisor retains brand control and earns ongoing royalties. The franchisee builds equity, cash flow, and a transferable asset.

Matt walked Jim through the math: going from eight locations to a thousand would require outside capital one way or another. The question is what you give up to get there. Equity investors take a permanent stake. Franchisees pay royalties, but they also carry the labor, the lease, and the day to day risk. For a founder with a proven, replicable model, that trade off can be very favorable.

The threshold for franchisability, according to Matt: if a stranger with motivation and purpose can replicate what you do to 60 to 80 percent accuracy using your systems, you probably have a franchisable business. Most successful systems prove the concept at several units before expanding, so they can show incoming candidates real numbers across real markets. Working with a franchise consultant helps both sides: founders evaluating whether to franchise their business, and candidates evaluating whether to enter one.

The Industries Most Candidates Never Consider

Ask most people to name franchise industries and they say food, hotels, maybe fitness. The real list runs to 80-plus categories. Franchises sell water. They coach executives. They handle sign making, insurance, banking, home painting, senior care, and everything between. Matt’s point is not to overwhelm candidates. It is to make sure they do not rule out categories before they understand them.

B2B franchises are a particularly good fit for people transitioning out of corporate careers. They are used to relationship based selling, comfortable with a recurring revenue model, and accustomed to hearing no before they hear yes. A B2B franchise owner who can knock on 100 doors, close 10 sales, and retain those clients on a recurring basis is building a real business, without a storefront, without retail hours, and without inventory risk. Many B2B franchise categories let owners build an agency model under them, adding staff as revenue grows. Understanding how franchise ownership works before picking a category saves candidates months of wasted evaluation.

How to Read a Franchise Disclosure Document

The FDD is a regulated, standardized document that every franchisor must provide before a sale. It runs roughly 200 pages and covers everything from the franchisor’s legal history to audited financials to the list of every active and terminated franchisee. Most candidates skim it. Experienced candidates read Item 19 (financial performance representations), Item 20 (franchisee turnover data), and the contact information for past and present owners.

Turnover data is the tell. A system with low turnover typically means owners are satisfied with the fit. High turnover, especially among franchisees who left before their agreement expired, is a sign the model is not working at the unit level. Matt’s rule: look at the numbers, then pick up the phone. Speak to owners at year one, year three, and year five. Ask them what the worst part is. Ask what surprised them. Ask what they would do differently. Those questions surface the truth that a curated reference list will not. The full evaluation process includes FDD review, validation calls, and discovery day, each step giving the candidate a clearer picture before signing.

Red Flags Every Franchise Candidate Should Watch For

Not all franchise systems are built to help their owners succeed. Matt recalled a sandwich franchise he saw at industry shows 25 and 30 years ago: delicious product, damaging culture. The number of sandwiches an owner had to sell each month just to cover their royalty obligation was impossibly high. That brand grew fast and then collapsed faster. Candidates who read the FDD and called current owners would have spotted the unit economics problem before signing.

The single clearest red flag: a franchisor that makes its profit on the franchise fee rather than royalties. Royalty revenue is tied directly to franchisee revenue. A franchisor aligned on royalties needs you to succeed. One aligned on fees just needs you to sign. Beyond the fee structure, watch for franchise systems that provide no independent franchisee validation, no documented support infrastructure, and no improvement track record. The best systems, as Matt put it, continuously update their layout, their marketing, and their operations, and they take feedback from the field. The McDonald’s fish sandwich came from a franchisee suggestion. Systems that can accept input from their owners tend to stay relevant. Those that cannot tend to stagnate. An experienced franchise consultant can help candidates identify these warning signs before they commit capital.

Schedule Flexibility: The Hidden Value Most Candidates Overlook

Return on investment matters. So does what the investment does to your life. Matt spent years in painting, at CertaPro Painters, a brand that has grown into a large, nationwide network of franchisees, and the detail he remembers most is not revenue. It is the day he could tell a customer that his next availability was eight weeks out on a Thursday. Everything in between was entirely his to decide. He called it a life changing realization.

Schedule flexibility is not uniform across franchise categories. Retail franchises demand consistent hours because the store has to be open. Home services such as painting, cleaning, and repair operate on scheduled appointments, which means owners control their own calendars in ways that retail almost never allows. Semi-active franchise models take this further, with a manager running day to day operations while the owner oversees from a distance. Candidates who care about schedule control should filter their franchise search by that criterion early, not treat it as a secondary consideration.

Why Senior Care Is One of the Strongest Franchise Categories Right Now

Senior care gets overlooked because it does not carry the brand recognition of fast food or fitness. But the fundamentals are exceptional: 40 to 70 franchise systems operating nationwide, a demographic tailwind that will run for decades as the baby boomer generation ages, and repeat customers built on trust rather than a single transaction. Owners who connect with the mission, supporting seniors and their families through an emotionally significant time, tend to build a business they find personally meaningful as well as durable.

Matt highlighted senior care as a franchise category that combines recurring revenue, growing demand, and high owner satisfaction. It also requires relatively lower overhead than retail based models, since the service is typically delivered in the client’s home. For candidates evaluating categories, it belongs on the short list.

The Compelling Emotional Reason That Separates Candidates Who Follow Through

Matt’s most direct observation about who actually completes the franchise process and thrives: everyone needs a compelling emotional reason. Not a financial calculation. A reason. Some candidates have seven figures sitting idle and want to put it to work. Others want to build a legacy asset for their children. Others have simply hit the ceiling of what a corporate salary will ever give them and know they need a different path.

Without that reason, the process stalls. The learning curve becomes too steep. The financial commitment feels too large. The vulnerability of starting something new is too uncomfortable. But with a clear reason, a vision of what the business will make possible, candidates push through all of it. That is the real difference between the people who finish the process and the people who stall out at the first hard week. Start a conversation with Matt to explore what franchise opportunity aligns with your goals.

“For anyone to make a change, you have to have what I call a compelling emotional reason to do something different, to endure the learning curve, to put forth money, to set aside your pride, to feel vulnerable.”

Matt Stevens, The CEO Project Podcast
Matt Stevens, Independent Franchise Consultant with nearly 40 years in franchising, The Franchise Guy

Matt Stevens Independent Franchise Consultant, The Franchise Guy

Nearly 40 Years in Franchising  |  4 Businesses Owned  |  Nearly 1,000 Franchisees Placed  |  heisthefranchiseguy.com

Matt Stevens has spent nearly 40 years in franchising. He’s helped more than 3,000 people explore franchise ownership and placed nearly 1,000 of them as franchisees across more than 40 states. He has owned four businesses and served as Vice President and Partner in a $2 billion international franchise holding company. He works as an independent franchise consultant based in Dublin, Ohio, and his consulting is free to the candidate. Learn more about Matt

Published:  |  Last Updated:  |  LinkedIn

Frequently Asked Questions

Franchising is a licensing agreement in which a franchisor grants a franchisee the right to operate a business under the franchisor’s brand, systems, and processes in exchange for an initial franchise fee and ongoing royalties. The franchisee owns and operates their location, invests their own capital, and keeps the profit after expenses and royalties. The franchisor provides training, marketing systems, and a proven operating model. Both sides succeed when the unit is healthy, which is why royalties, not franchise fees, are where reputable franchisors make their money.

More than 80 industries have active franchise systems. The list goes well beyond the food and hotel categories most people think of first. It includes home services, fitness, senior care, B2B business coaching, sales coaching, insurance, banking, sign making, cleaning, painting, water treatment, and dozens more. There are currently over 4,000 active franchise brands operating in the United States. Most people underestimate this range and rule out strong options before they have a chance to evaluate them on the criteria that matter: investment level, schedule flexibility, customer type, and fit with their goals.

Well-run franchisors earn the bulk of their revenue from royalties, a percentage of each franchisee’s gross sales, typically ranging from four to ten percent depending on the industry. The initial franchise fee generally covers the cost of onboarding, training, and early marketing support. Most established franchisors do not profit significantly on the fee itself. A franchisor whose primary income comes from franchise fees rather than royalties is a warning sign: their incentive ends at the signing rather than at the franchisee’s ongoing success. Royalty driven franchisors have a structural reason to support you after launch.

Some founders begin franchising before their first location is open, when the model exists entirely in concept, but most successful franchisors prove the system at several units first. The key question is whether a motivated person with no prior experience in your industry could replicate your results to roughly 60 to 80 percent accuracy using your documented systems. If yes, the model may be franchisable. If the owner’s personal skill or relationships are doing most of the work, systemization is the prerequisite. Building out the training programs, legal documents, and operational infrastructure to support franchisees typically costs six figures to low seven figures and takes years, not months.

Ready to Find the Right Franchise for Your Life?

It’s not for everyone, but it might make sense to find out. Matt Stevens has helped more than 3,000 people explore franchising and placed nearly 1,000 of them as franchisees across more than 40 states, free to every candidate he works with. Every business starts with one and grows, and many others have done it before you, so you can too. Take the quiz on his site to see which categories fit your goals, your investment range, and your schedule, or book a free 15 minute consultation to talk it through with Matt directly.

Talk to Matt. It’s Free

Related Posts

How to Validate a Franchise Before You Sign

How to Validate a Franchise Before You Sign

How to validate a franchise: who to call, how many owners to talk to, and the questions to ask before…
How to Start a Franchise: From Signing Day to Opening Day

How to Start a Franchise: From Signing Day to Opening Day

How to start a franchise after you sign: the agreement, financing, location, training, hiring, and opening day, explained by Matt…
Franchise Financing Options and How to Choose the Right Mix

Franchise Financing Options and How to Choose the Right Mix

Franchise financing options include SBA loans, franchisor financing, ROBS, home equity, and cash. Matt Stevens explains how to choose the…